Elmhurst put together a determined and hard-fought effort on Tuesday night inside R.A. Faganel Hall, but the Bluejays were unable to overcome Manchester University's dominant showing on the glass, falling 68–59 in a non-conference matchup. Elmhurst battled from start to finish, responding repeatedly to Manchester runs and putting together strong stretches on both ends of the floor, yet the Spartans' 48–23 rebounding advantage proved too difficult to counter as second-chance points and extra possessions tilted the game.  The Bluejays were able to pull within four in the second half, but Manchester answered quickly.

Despite the uphill battle on the boards, the Bluejays showed resilience throughout the contest. Anna Kleszynski delivered a standout performance, posting a double-double with 12 points and 10 rebounds while adding five steals to anchor Elmhurst defensively. Kristin Bukata provided consistent offense with 11 points, six assists and a pair of rebounds in a full 40-minute effort. Natalie Robinson added nine points and five rebounds, while Maia Lewers chipped in eight points, including several key drives that kept the Jays within striking distance.

After trailing 33–24 at halftime, Elmhurst surged in the third quarter. The Bluejays strung together stops, forced several turnovers, and attacked the paint to trim the margin. Elmhurst outscored Manchester 8–4 in points off turnovers during that stretch and continued to push the pace into the fourth quarter. The Bluejays posted their best offensive frame in the closing period, scoring 21 points and battling until the final buzzer.

Elmhurst finished the night shooting 22-of-60 from the field while scoring 32 points in the paint. Defensively, the Bluejays collected 12 steals and forced 24 Manchester turnovers.

The Bluejays will look to build on Tuesday's competitive performance as they continue non-conference play Saturday at the University of Chicago.